In Capital Hill, south of downtown OKC, there’s a culinary gem serving deliciousness since 1924. Welcome to Coney Island, a place where time seems to have stood still, and the food is as comforting as a warm hug from an old friend.

This unassuming eatery is a beloved institution that has been feeding the city’s hot dog cravings for nearly a century. With a menu that’s as straightforward as it gets, Coney Island specializes in hot dogs, Greek spaghetti, and Frito chili pie; all served up in an atmosphere that’s as vintage as the recipes.

The hot dogs here are legendary. The #2, a coney with mustard, chili, cheese, and onions, is a crowd favorite. But don’t overlook the Greek spaghetti, a hearty plate of noodles smothered in their signature chili and cheese. And if you’re feeling adventurous, why not try their Frito chili pie?

But it’s not just the food that makes Coney Island a must-visit. The restaurant itself is a slice of history, with its old-school decor and walls adorned with Sooner sports memorabilia. It’s a place that transports you back in time, offering a glimpse of what OKC was like 50 years ago.

However, be warned, this place is cash only, so make sure you’ve got some green in your pocket before you walk in. And while the parking can be a bit of a challenge in Capital Hill, the mouthwatering food and the trip down memory lane make it all worth it.

So, if you’re in Oklahoma City and looking for a taste of tradition, head on over to Coney Island. It’s a place where the food is comforting, the service is quick, and the experience is unforgettable. Just remember to bring your appetite and a sense of nostalgia.

Visit our complete OKC Hole-in-the-Wall Dining Guide.